Beethoven's 'Coriolan' overture occupies a very specific place among his works. It is the only major piece of Beethoven that ends tragically.
It is superfluous to say Beethoven is not superficial - to put it very mildly. He encapsulates intense struggle, hardship, force, energy, effort, but he is determinedly optimistic. Victory comes only as a result of great effort but it comes - this combination being one of the reasons he has been the most popular of all composers. Beethoven was indeed the last classical composer of the first rank to have an unequivocally optimistic view of the world in the last analysis – later Mendelssohn was also optimistic but he is precisely not a composer of the very first rank. It is merely necessary to compare music being composed by Schubert during the last years of Beethoven’s life to see the comparison.
Perhaps for that reason Beethoven’s Coriolan poses particular problems of interpretation that only the greatest conductors are capable of solving. Outstanding recorded successes for me are Carlos Kleiber (on DVD), Konwitschny, and Klemperer. But Furtwangler’s 1943 recording occupies a place among the pantheon of the greatest recordings of anything. The extraordinary force and violence of the interpretation, combined with Furtwangler’s typical sustaining of the full value of notes, gives the impression of someone implacably crushed. Overwhelming.
Showing posts with label Beethoven. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beethoven. Show all posts
Monday, 7 July 2008
Friday, 27 June 2008
Beethoven's Eroica - Toscanini 1939, Klemperer 1955
Both are, of course, extremely famous recordings. I have listened to the Toscanini on the excellent and widely praised transfer of the entire 1939 cycle on Music & Arts - another advantage of this set, incidentally, being the highly informative notes by Christopher Dyment.
The fame of the 1939 recording is fully justified, and not everything lives up to its reputation, but to me it has features which differ somewhat from those sometimes carelessly attributed to Toscanini.
The concept of a 'heroic' symphony, and in this case the name is applied by Beethoven, obviously implies someone considerably away from the average. If we take another famous interpreter of the symphony, Klemperer, the power of his interpretation lies in the remorseless and inevitable character of the music - the 'granite will' to use a hackneyed but appropriate phrase. This is achieved by a minimum of tempo changes and Klemperer's 'vertically equal' tone - that is avoidance of domination by the top line with his characteristic strong emphasis to the bass and woodwind. The result is somewhere between a force of nature and a human being. All Klemperer's readings, with their integration of long line, including careful placing and grading of dynamics throughout the work, have the feeling of inevitability - that once the first notes have sounded the rest follows inevitably.
Toscanini's hero is more human. The tempo fluctuations, contrary to Toscanini's reputation, are much greater in the first movement than Klemperer's - not only in the latter's famous 1955 recording but in any of his other recorded performances. In the quieter passages Toscanini's hero either pauses for breath or thought - the momentum of the music slowed by a deceleration in tempo. This makes the ensuing onslaught the more striking. Toscanini's hero rather than having a 'granite will' has a more human 'indomitable will' - that is, whatever the pauses, in which relaxation occurse in a way it does not in Klemperer, the struggle is resumed. This means the outburst at the centre of the funeral march has a more human character, for a person who was not without a quieter or softer side, than Klemperer's.
Within the framework that Beethoven's hero is clearly a public person, Toscanini's funeral march has slightly more the element of mourning by those who knew the exceptional figure personally whereas Klemperer's is a great formal funeral.
These are, of course, distinctions within the very highest grade of musical interpretation. But the slightly more subjective character of the Toscanini interpretation is not in line with some stereotyped 'conventional wisdoms' regarding him.
Again it should be noted that there is not some 'spirit' separate from the notes as performed. The different impact is traceable to entirely comprehensible differences in the performance.
The fame of the 1939 recording is fully justified, and not everything lives up to its reputation, but to me it has features which differ somewhat from those sometimes carelessly attributed to Toscanini.
The concept of a 'heroic' symphony, and in this case the name is applied by Beethoven, obviously implies someone considerably away from the average. If we take another famous interpreter of the symphony, Klemperer, the power of his interpretation lies in the remorseless and inevitable character of the music - the 'granite will' to use a hackneyed but appropriate phrase. This is achieved by a minimum of tempo changes and Klemperer's 'vertically equal' tone - that is avoidance of domination by the top line with his characteristic strong emphasis to the bass and woodwind. The result is somewhere between a force of nature and a human being. All Klemperer's readings, with their integration of long line, including careful placing and grading of dynamics throughout the work, have the feeling of inevitability - that once the first notes have sounded the rest follows inevitably.
Toscanini's hero is more human. The tempo fluctuations, contrary to Toscanini's reputation, are much greater in the first movement than Klemperer's - not only in the latter's famous 1955 recording but in any of his other recorded performances. In the quieter passages Toscanini's hero either pauses for breath or thought - the momentum of the music slowed by a deceleration in tempo. This makes the ensuing onslaught the more striking. Toscanini's hero rather than having a 'granite will' has a more human 'indomitable will' - that is, whatever the pauses, in which relaxation occurse in a way it does not in Klemperer, the struggle is resumed. This means the outburst at the centre of the funeral march has a more human character, for a person who was not without a quieter or softer side, than Klemperer's.
Within the framework that Beethoven's hero is clearly a public person, Toscanini's funeral march has slightly more the element of mourning by those who knew the exceptional figure personally whereas Klemperer's is a great formal funeral.
These are, of course, distinctions within the very highest grade of musical interpretation. But the slightly more subjective character of the Toscanini interpretation is not in line with some stereotyped 'conventional wisdoms' regarding him.
Again it should be noted that there is not some 'spirit' separate from the notes as performed. The different impact is traceable to entirely comprehensible differences in the performance.
Sunday, 22 June 2008
Toscanini, Furtwangler and 'Britishness'
As it is in line with majority opinion it is hardly suprising I rate Toscanini and Furtwangler as the greatest of conductors and would only rank Klemperer and Mravinsky in the same premier league (de Sabata and Carlos Kleiber would possibly enter it but there is too little remaining of their output to be comparable).
I therefore do subscribe to either the 'up with Furtwangler down with Toscanini' or vice versa schools. But in one field Toscanini was absolutely decisively superior - strangely enough it casts light on the attempted political strategy of Gordon Brown and supporters.
The sphere Toscanini was decisively superior in was his political stance. Due to Furtwangler's musical greatness attempts have been made to justify his remaining in Nazi Germany, claiming that he was working for resistance from within or was even a 'hero'. Ths is nonesense. 'Resistance' in Germany via music was an absurd utopia - indeed all the resistance in Nazi Germany, apart from the superb and heroic work done by those who spied for Nazi Germany's enemies, led to nothing - nor was Furtwangler involved in political opposition to the regime. The right stance, in addition to Jewish musicians who were forced to flee, was taken by Erich Kleiber who left the country in protest against the Nazi regime.
As there was no obstacle to Furtwangler leaving, he would merely not have been able to return, Arthur Rubinstein was entirely correct when he said: 'Had Furtwängler been firm in his democratic convictions he would have left Germany'.
Toscanini, after some early slight confusion regarding Mussolini when fascism was a new phenomenon, took a totally clear position. He refused to perform in Nazi Germany, Nazi Austria or fascist Italy. He openly supported the defeat of both his own Italy and Germany in World War II - when Furtwangler's concerts were being broadcast as part an attempt to raise morale among German troops (fortunately scarcely a decisive contribution to the war effort).
What has all this got to do with the attempted political strategy of Gordon Brown and his supporters? They have attempted to make 'Britishness' their political touchstone. But the events referred to above remind us that it is universal human values, not patriotism, that are the highest value. The Germans who took the right choice were those such as Thomas Mann, Erich Kleiber, Marlene Dietrich and others who openly called, and campaigned for, the defeat of their own country in World War II. Those who showed patriotism and directly or indirectly supported the victory of their own country took the wrong choice.
Patriotism in short is not the highest moral ground - universal human values are. The attempt to construct an ideology based on 'Britishness' is wrong for a number of reasons but most decisive of all is that it is not on the highest moral ground. That, among other reasons, is why this attempt to create a 'Britishness' ideology appears intellectually cramped and without adequate purchase.
I therefore do subscribe to either the 'up with Furtwangler down with Toscanini' or vice versa schools. But in one field Toscanini was absolutely decisively superior - strangely enough it casts light on the attempted political strategy of Gordon Brown and supporters.
The sphere Toscanini was decisively superior in was his political stance. Due to Furtwangler's musical greatness attempts have been made to justify his remaining in Nazi Germany, claiming that he was working for resistance from within or was even a 'hero'. Ths is nonesense. 'Resistance' in Germany via music was an absurd utopia - indeed all the resistance in Nazi Germany, apart from the superb and heroic work done by those who spied for Nazi Germany's enemies, led to nothing - nor was Furtwangler involved in political opposition to the regime. The right stance, in addition to Jewish musicians who were forced to flee, was taken by Erich Kleiber who left the country in protest against the Nazi regime.
As there was no obstacle to Furtwangler leaving, he would merely not have been able to return, Arthur Rubinstein was entirely correct when he said: 'Had Furtwängler been firm in his democratic convictions he would have left Germany'.
Toscanini, after some early slight confusion regarding Mussolini when fascism was a new phenomenon, took a totally clear position. He refused to perform in Nazi Germany, Nazi Austria or fascist Italy. He openly supported the defeat of both his own Italy and Germany in World War II - when Furtwangler's concerts were being broadcast as part an attempt to raise morale among German troops (fortunately scarcely a decisive contribution to the war effort).
What has all this got to do with the attempted political strategy of Gordon Brown and his supporters? They have attempted to make 'Britishness' their political touchstone. But the events referred to above remind us that it is universal human values, not patriotism, that are the highest value. The Germans who took the right choice were those such as Thomas Mann, Erich Kleiber, Marlene Dietrich and others who openly called, and campaigned for, the defeat of their own country in World War II. Those who showed patriotism and directly or indirectly supported the victory of their own country took the wrong choice.
Patriotism in short is not the highest moral ground - universal human values are. The attempt to construct an ideology based on 'Britishness' is wrong for a number of reasons but most decisive of all is that it is not on the highest moral ground. That, among other reasons, is why this attempt to create a 'Britishness' ideology appears intellectually cramped and without adequate purchase.
Beethoven's Eroica - Bohm 1961
Bohm is a conductor who poses a number of problems. I knew that he was acquainted with Hitler and found his later 'explanation' that anyone prominent at the time knew Hitler much less than convincing. The following entry from Wikipedia, which I have just turned to, makes it far clearer.
'It is believed that Böhm was an early sympathizer of the Nazi party, although he never became a member. In November 1923 he stopped a rehearsal in the Munich opera house in order, reportedly, to watch Adolf Hitler's Beer Hall Putsch.[2] In 1930 he is said to have become angry when his wife was accused by Nazi brownshirts of being Jewish during the premiere of Arnold Schoenberg's opera Von heute auf morgen and to have stated that he would "tell Hitler about this".[2] When he was music director in Darmstadt and Hamburg he allegedly complained of "too many Jews" among the musicians he worked with.[2]
'While music director in Dresden he "poured forth rhetoric glorifying the Nazi regime and its cultural aims" according to one commentator.[3]
'A more certain story is that in the wake of the Nazi annexation of Austria he gave the Hitler salute during a concert with the Vienna Philharmonic, ironically violating Nazi rules about places where the greeting was appropriate.[2] After the referendum controlled by the Nazis to justify the annexation, or Anschluss, the conductor allegedly declared that "anyone who does not approve this act of our Führer with a hundred-per-cent YES does not deserve to bear the honourable name of a German!"[2]' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Bohm
There is no one to one relation between musical ability and politics, and Bohm's 1961 recording of the Eroica is to my mind a fine one, but it is unclear how Bohm appears to have slipped through the de-Nazification net, if this is the case, more easily than Furtwangler who made the mistake of staying in Germany during the Nazi period but who is well known to have appeared to have shown no support, and some small scale resistance, to the Nazi regime.
Musically it is the rhyhmic firmness and strength of Bohm that makes this reading notable.
'It is believed that Böhm was an early sympathizer of the Nazi party, although he never became a member. In November 1923 he stopped a rehearsal in the Munich opera house in order, reportedly, to watch Adolf Hitler's Beer Hall Putsch.[2] In 1930 he is said to have become angry when his wife was accused by Nazi brownshirts of being Jewish during the premiere of Arnold Schoenberg's opera Von heute auf morgen and to have stated that he would "tell Hitler about this".[2] When he was music director in Darmstadt and Hamburg he allegedly complained of "too many Jews" among the musicians he worked with.[2]
'While music director in Dresden he "poured forth rhetoric glorifying the Nazi regime and its cultural aims" according to one commentator.[3]
'A more certain story is that in the wake of the Nazi annexation of Austria he gave the Hitler salute during a concert with the Vienna Philharmonic, ironically violating Nazi rules about places where the greeting was appropriate.[2] After the referendum controlled by the Nazis to justify the annexation, or Anschluss, the conductor allegedly declared that "anyone who does not approve this act of our Führer with a hundred-per-cent YES does not deserve to bear the honourable name of a German!"[2]' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Bohm
There is no one to one relation between musical ability and politics, and Bohm's 1961 recording of the Eroica is to my mind a fine one, but it is unclear how Bohm appears to have slipped through the de-Nazification net, if this is the case, more easily than Furtwangler who made the mistake of staying in Germany during the Nazi period but who is well known to have appeared to have shown no support, and some small scale resistance, to the Nazi regime.
Musically it is the rhyhmic firmness and strength of Bohm that makes this reading notable.
Friday, 20 June 2008
Why Norrington is wrong on Beethoven, Haydn and Brahms
In an argument supporting the authentic instruments movement Roger Norrington used as a justification for a certain style in Beethoven that of course Beethoven was closer chronologically to Haydn than to Brahms. Unfortunately this is highly misleading as it implicitly believes all time has an equal impact. Haydn is a composer formed prior to the French Revolution. Beethoven is a composer formed during and after the impact of the French Revolution - Brahms is of course a post French Revolution composer. In years Haydn and Beethoven are closer together than Beethoven and Brahms, but in terms of the character of the world in which they lived Beethoven and Brahms are closer together than Haydn and Beethoven. This naturally does not 'justify' any post-Wagnerian style of Beethoven conducting, reasons that have been dealt with in another post http://blogger-ablog.blogspot.com/2008/06/hegel-and-authentic-instruments.html. It however means Norrington's statement is essentially misleading.
Thursday, 19 June 2008
Beethoven's Eroica - Karajan 1962
The Eroica is, highly non-originally, one of the most central pieces of music for me. I have more than seventy recordings.
Karajan, as will be known from other posts here, is not one of my top rated conductors. Beethoven can be both unrestrained and savage - attributes that are clearly linked. Karajan's moulded orchestral textures do not fit this. The first movement in Karajan's 1962 recording of the Eroica therefore strikes me as underpowered.
However, the second movement funeral march, in contrast, strikes me as a fine reading for two reasons - both illustrating that there is no 'spirit' over and apart from the notes actually played but the impression is in the way it is played.
First the somewhat moulded orchestral texture, the lack of savagery, produces a certain, but not excessive, feeling of restraint. This is suitable. A sleeve note to a recording of Mahler 2nd symphony made the intelligent comment that Beethoven in the funeral march in the Eroica was thinking of the mourners (or it might be put as the occassion of the death of a hero), whereas Mahler in the funeral piece starting his 2nd symphony was thinking of the corpse (or it might be put as the fear of death). That Beethoven's funeral march has the feeling of a public or state occassion, or of heroism in the face of death, an element of restraint is not out of place.
The second feature is the way that in the central section of the movement Karajan both gives prominence to the trumpet part but integrates it in the texture - an example of moulding. This gives a 'military' character which is in place in this piece known to be originally associated with Napoleon.
Despite my reservations on Karajan therefore it is a reading of stature of one of the greatest pieces of music - no wonder Toscanini, at one of his last rehersals, performed it so to speak 'for himself' to appreciate the greatness of a work he had conducted his entire life.
Karajan, as will be known from other posts here, is not one of my top rated conductors. Beethoven can be both unrestrained and savage - attributes that are clearly linked. Karajan's moulded orchestral textures do not fit this. The first movement in Karajan's 1962 recording of the Eroica therefore strikes me as underpowered.
However, the second movement funeral march, in contrast, strikes me as a fine reading for two reasons - both illustrating that there is no 'spirit' over and apart from the notes actually played but the impression is in the way it is played.
First the somewhat moulded orchestral texture, the lack of savagery, produces a certain, but not excessive, feeling of restraint. This is suitable. A sleeve note to a recording of Mahler 2nd symphony made the intelligent comment that Beethoven in the funeral march in the Eroica was thinking of the mourners (or it might be put as the occassion of the death of a hero), whereas Mahler in the funeral piece starting his 2nd symphony was thinking of the corpse (or it might be put as the fear of death). That Beethoven's funeral march has the feeling of a public or state occassion, or of heroism in the face of death, an element of restraint is not out of place.
The second feature is the way that in the central section of the movement Karajan both gives prominence to the trumpet part but integrates it in the texture - an example of moulding. This gives a 'military' character which is in place in this piece known to be originally associated with Napoleon.
Despite my reservations on Karajan therefore it is a reading of stature of one of the greatest pieces of music - no wonder Toscanini, at one of his last rehersals, performed it so to speak 'for himself' to appreciate the greatness of a work he had conducted his entire life.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
